Every sport starts with a General template built for young or unspecialized players. Once a player settles into a role, position-specific templates take over, so the evaluation matches how they're actually being coached.
Every category is scored against what's realistic for the player's age, not against a pro athlete or an older teammate.
Every category carries at least five tags on each side. That floor never drops, even as templates get refined over time.
Each category includes one question to keep the coach's scoring focused on what actually matters for that skill.
Every report card has space for the coach to say something specific to that player, not just to their scores.